The French Revolution is attacking the American Revolution
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
The French Revolution is attacking the American Revolution
https://www.discovery.org/human/2021/03/07/the-french-revolution-is-attacking-the-american-revolution/
Realizing that the neo-French and American Revolutions are not all one thing but in the real world can share attributes, we can make the following general observations:
The French Revolution is Utopian and believes in the perfectibility of society that requires a strong centralized power structure. The American Revolution is, paradoxically, conservative. Its locus of power is the free individual.
The French Revolution focuses on self-indulgence. The American, on self-restraint.
The French Revolution is authoritarian. It deploys institutional power to coerce adherence to the revolution’s values. In today’s parlance, that goal is equity, meaning equality of outcomes. The American Revolution stands for equality of opportunity, by creating a system in which people are enabled to go as far as their talent and character allow without regard to the color of their skin, their sex, or any other categorization.
The French Revolution tolerates only approved speech. It dictates acceptable lexicon. The American Revolution understands that reasonable people may differ. The answer to bad speech isn’t to punish but refute it with better speech.
The French Revolution detests traditional religion—particularly orthodox Christianity—and seeks to establish a mandatory secularity in the public sphere to which all must give obeisance. (For example, the Equality Act would impose transgendered ideology throughout society, including forcing women’s sports to let biological males compete.) The American Revolution upholds the free exercise of religion—that is, the right to live according to the precepts of one’s faith—as a fundamental human right. (Thus, religious pacifists may legally escape conscription into the military, even in times of war.)
The French Revolution feels, that is, its arguments are based mostly in hyper emotionalism. Its great potent tools are moral panic and the aroused mob sweeping all before it. No disagreement allowed. The American Revolution thinks. Its most effective strategy is free and open discourse as applied to established moral and legal principles, from which people are allowed to dissent.
The French Revolution believes in “positive rights” secured by an all-powerful government—even if that means citizens are coerced into their provision. The American Revolution perceives rights as emanating from God or as integral to human nature. Thus, government isn’t established to guarantee happiness but maintain an open and free society for its pursuit.
The Bible says we will be known by our fruits. I think that is also true of philosophical systems.
The historic fruits of the French Revolution have been despotism, death, and destruction—in the Reign of Terror in France, the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia, and catastrophic Cultural Revolution of China, all of which were pursued with French Revolutionary values and zealotry.
The fruits of the American Revolution have been rising levels of personal freedom in the West unheard of in human history and the creation of the most prosperous society on earth. It is why downtrodden people from the world risk life and limb to get to the United States. They believe in the American Dream.
It will take time for the passions fueling our American French Revolution to bank. But if we stay resolute and defiant, if we resist succumbing to the Jacobins’ bullying, that day will come. As the old saying goes, the Revolution always eats its own.
But I fear our situation is going to get worse before it gets better. Today, Dr. Seuss was canceled. Tomorrow it could be Mr. Rogers—he was, after all a white, male, Christian pastor, who depicted living in a privileged suburban neighborhood, and spoke to his audience of children in the oppressive binary terms, “boys and girls.” Off with his head!
Bears repeating: The Revolution always eats its own. Perhaps that is why we are seeing the militarization of DC. Perhaps the Democrat cheats fill it in their bones. :drinks2:
And i am hoping for the same justice for democrat tyrants that the leaders of the french revolution received.
Realizing that the neo-French and American Revolutions are not all one thing but in the real world can share attributes, we can make the following general observations:
The French Revolution is Utopian and believes in the perfectibility of society that requires a strong centralized power structure. The American Revolution is, paradoxically, conservative. Its locus of power is the free individual.
The French Revolution focuses on self-indulgence. The American, on self-restraint.
The French Revolution is authoritarian. It deploys institutional power to coerce adherence to the revolution’s values. In today’s parlance, that goal is equity, meaning equality of outcomes. The American Revolution stands for equality of opportunity, by creating a system in which people are enabled to go as far as their talent and character allow without regard to the color of their skin, their sex, or any other categorization.
The French Revolution tolerates only approved speech. It dictates acceptable lexicon. The American Revolution understands that reasonable people may differ. The answer to bad speech isn’t to punish but refute it with better speech.
The French Revolution detests traditional religion—particularly orthodox Christianity—and seeks to establish a mandatory secularity in the public sphere to which all must give obeisance. (For example, the Equality Act would impose transgendered ideology throughout society, including forcing women’s sports to let biological males compete.) The American Revolution upholds the free exercise of religion—that is, the right to live according to the precepts of one’s faith—as a fundamental human right. (Thus, religious pacifists may legally escape conscription into the military, even in times of war.)
The French Revolution feels, that is, its arguments are based mostly in hyper emotionalism. Its great potent tools are moral panic and the aroused mob sweeping all before it. No disagreement allowed. The American Revolution thinks. Its most effective strategy is free and open discourse as applied to established moral and legal principles, from which people are allowed to dissent.
The French Revolution believes in “positive rights” secured by an all-powerful government—even if that means citizens are coerced into their provision. The American Revolution perceives rights as emanating from God or as integral to human nature. Thus, government isn’t established to guarantee happiness but maintain an open and free society for its pursuit.
The Bible says we will be known by our fruits. I think that is also true of philosophical systems.
The historic fruits of the French Revolution have been despotism, death, and destruction—in the Reign of Terror in France, the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia, and catastrophic Cultural Revolution of China, all of which were pursued with French Revolutionary values and zealotry.
The fruits of the American Revolution have been rising levels of personal freedom in the West unheard of in human history and the creation of the most prosperous society on earth. It is why downtrodden people from the world risk life and limb to get to the United States. They believe in the American Dream.
It will take time for the passions fueling our American French Revolution to bank. But if we stay resolute and defiant, if we resist succumbing to the Jacobins’ bullying, that day will come. As the old saying goes, the Revolution always eats its own.
But I fear our situation is going to get worse before it gets better. Today, Dr. Seuss was canceled. Tomorrow it could be Mr. Rogers—he was, after all a white, male, Christian pastor, who depicted living in a privileged suburban neighborhood, and spoke to his audience of children in the oppressive binary terms, “boys and girls.” Off with his head!
Bears repeating: The Revolution always eats its own. Perhaps that is why we are seeing the militarization of DC. Perhaps the Democrat cheats fill it in their bones. :drinks2:
And i am hoping for the same justice for democrat tyrants that the leaders of the french revolution received.
Calypso Jones- Posts : 28659
Points : 38663
Reputation : 570
Join date : 2021-02-09
Age : 24
HawkTheSlayer likes this post
Re: The French Revolution is attacking the American Revolution
The American Revolution sets others free so that they are able to oppress us........and that's exactly what they are doing with that freedom.
It's a catch-22 situation........
It's a catch-22 situation........
Jen- Posts : 695
Points : 2179
Reputation : 58
Join date : 2021-03-25
HawkTheSlayer likes this post
Similar topics
» We Need a Revolution
» Hating God and Christianity/attacking believers has become acceptable.
» A Revolution in the minds of the People
» One cat keeps attacking my smaller one. Any ideas ?
» Gutter Media attacking DeSantis
» Hating God and Christianity/attacking believers has become acceptable.
» A Revolution in the minds of the People
» One cat keeps attacking my smaller one. Any ideas ?
» Gutter Media attacking DeSantis
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum